Bars

Magoo’s Pub & Pizza

4.7 142 reviews 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM 1802 Schuyler Ave, Lafayette, IN 47902, United States

Discover this place

Magoo’s Pub & Pizza is a vibrant local establishment located in Lafayette, Indiana, known for its delightful combination of hearty pizzas and a cozy pub atmosphere. Our story began with a passion for creating mouthwatering deep-dish masterpieces, including Chicago and Detroit styles that are beloved by the community. With a focus on great beer selections, live music, and a welcoming vibe, Magoo's serves as the perfect gathering spot for friends and families alike. Whether you’re savoring our famous Bosco Sticks or indulging in a rich fudge brownie, we guarantee a memorable dining experience that keeps you coming back for more.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Outdoor seating
Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery

Highlights

Bar games
Fast service
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Live music
Live performances
Sports

Popular for

Solo dining

Dining options

Seating
Table service

Amenities

Restroom
Wi-Fi

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy

Crowd

Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Magoo’s Pub & Pizza before visiting.

Reviews for Magoo’s Pub & Pizza

4.7

142 reviews

100%

22%

Review highlights

Based on 142 reviews

Magoo’s Pub & Pizza is widely praised for its generous, flavorful deep-dish pizzas, with many customers highlighting the Detroit and Chicago styles as must-tries. The brand benefits from a loyal local following that appreciates both the quality and affordability of the offerings, often noting the ample cheese and hearty portions. Guests also commend the relaxed atmosphere and the complementary beer selection, contributing to a well-rounded dining experience. While most feedback is positive, occasional suggestions include slight adjustments to sauce distribution to enhance flavor balance. Overall, Magoo’s is recognized as a standout pizza destination in Lafayette, delivering satisfying meals that encourage repeat visits.

Joe Clayton

Apr 01, 2025

Ordered the large Detroit style and damn it was good or should I stay part of it was good. I’ll be making about five meals out of this thing is so huge. Tons of extra cheese like I ordered. Only criticism would be maybe some more tomato sauce spread out over the pizza.

Steven Cain

Mar 31, 2025

Now this is pizza! Somehow I missed that Magoo's Pizza was still around. Now that I know, we will be going back.

Mick La Lopa

Mar 21, 2025

Once again, a restaurant owned and managed by Tom Riehle is a winner. Some of the best pizza in town at a reasonable price with a relaxing ambience. Treat yourself to a great pizza and beer.

Paul Bunch

Mar 15, 2025

My wife brought home a deep dish pizza last week from Magoo's. I'll admit, this was our first time having their pizza. Absolutely delicious, thick, and the price was very competitive with franchise establishments. We'll definitely be getting pizzas again from Magoo's! Thanks for a delicious meal!

Brittaney Casto

Feb 13, 2025

Hands down the best deep dish pizza in town. Try the deep dish Chicago and Detroit style.

Erin Darr

Feb 09, 2025

Very good local joint! The pizza was delicious! Lots of TV’s and friendly vibe.

Melinda Perkins

Jan 26, 2025

My husband and I came here a little snack and the pizza was soooo good, it's my new favorite. I would rate it an 8/10, next time I'm going to ask for my toppings on top rather than under the cheese, otherwise it's excellent. We also got some pretzel bites and they were pretty hard and crunchy but the beer cheese was tasty so I'll rate them a 5/10. The drinks were cold and made well. We will be back for our next pizza night

Kenny Catron

Jan 20, 2025

If I could give a sixth star, I would. No need to order extra cheese here like at all the other pizza joints.